By
·
11 minute read
Refinancing fees can feel like a maze of confusing charges, each with its own purpose and price point. Understanding what you're actually paying for helps you evaluate whether fees are reasonable, identify opportunities to negotiate, and budget accurately for your refinancing journey. Knowledge is power when it comes to managing these costs effectively.
This comprehensive guide provides an in-depth examination of the three major fee categories in refinancing—legal fees, valuation costs, and application charges. We'll explain what each fee covers, what influences their amounts, how they compare across providers, and strategies for ensuring you're getting fair value.
Legal Fees: What You're Really Paying For
Legal fees often represent one of your larger refinancing expenses, but many homeowners don't fully understand what these fees cover or why they're necessary.
Understanding the Lawyer's Role in Refinancing
Your lawyer or conveyancer performs essential functions that protect both you and your lender while ensuring all legal requirements are met. They conduct comprehensive title searches on your property to confirm ownership and identify any issues like easements, covenants, or encumbrances that might affect the refinancing.
They review your loan documentation thoroughly to ensure you understand all terms and conditions, identify any unusual clauses, and confirm everything is in order. Your lawyer handles the discharge of your existing mortgage by liaising with your current lender, obtaining discharge documentation, and ensuring the old mortgage is properly removed from your property title.
They prepare and register your new mortgage with Land Information New Zealand, creating the legal security interest that protects your new lender. They also manage all funds on settlement day, receiving money from your new lender, paying out your old mortgage, handling all fees and charges, and transferring any surplus equity to you if you're accessing additional funds.
Throughout this process, they provide legal advice and answer your questions, ensuring you understand your obligations and rights. This comprehensive service justifies the legal fees you pay.
Typical Legal Fee Ranges in New Zealand
Legal fees for straightforward refinancing typically range from six hundred to fifteen hundred dollars across New Zealand. However, several factors influence where your fees fall within this range.
Location significantly affects legal costs. Lawyers in Auckland, Wellington, and other major cities typically charge more than those in smaller towns and provincial areas. The higher cost of living and operating expenses in cities translates to higher fees, though you also often get faster service and greater expertise.
The complexity of your transaction matters considerably. Simple refinancing with no complications typically costs at the lower end of the range. Refinancing involving property ownership changes, dealing with multiple parties or complex titles, accessing significant equity or changing loan structures, or addressing separation or divorce situations typically costs more due to additional work required.
Your lawyer's experience and reputation also influence fees. Highly experienced lawyers specializing in property transactions might charge premium rates but often provide faster, more efficient service. Newer lawyers or those handling refinancing less frequently might charge less but could take longer or be less familiar with potential issues.
Some lawyers charge fixed fees for refinancing while others charge hourly rates. Fixed fees provide certainty and are common for straightforward refinancing, while hourly rates are more typical for complex situations where the total work required is difficult to predict upfront.
What's Included in Legal Fees
When your lawyer quotes a fee for refinancing, ask exactly what's included. Typical inclusions are professional time for reviewing documents and providing advice, conducting title searches and preparing legal documentation, liaising with lenders and coordinating settlement, and managing funds and ensuring proper distribution on settlement day.
However, some costs are typically charged separately as disbursements rather than being included in the legal fee. These include Land Information New Zealand registration fees, search fees for obtaining title and other official documents, courier or postal charges for document delivery, and travel costs if your lawyer needs to meet you at a location outside their office.
Get a comprehensive quote that breaks down both the legal fee and expected disbursements so you understand your total legal costs accurately.
Shopping for Legal Services
Legal fees vary significantly between providers, making comparison shopping worthwhile. Obtain quotes from at least three lawyers or conveyancers, asking each for their total estimated cost including disbursements, what specific services are included, their typical turnaround time for refinancing, and whether they're on your lender's approved panel, which can sometimes streamline the process.
Ask your mortgage broker for recommendations, as they work with lawyers regularly and know who provides good service at fair prices. Personal recommendations from friends or family who've recently refinanced can also identify reliable, cost-effective lawyers.
However, don't choose based solely on the lowest fee. Consider the lawyer's experience with refinancing, their responsiveness and communication style, their reputation and reviews from previous clients, and their ability to explain complex legal concepts clearly.
A lawyer who charges eight hundred dollars but completes your refinancing smoothly and efficiently provides better value than one who charges six hundred dollars but is slow, unresponsive, or makes mistakes that cause delays.
Negotiating Legal Fees
Legal fees are more negotiable than many people realize. If you've used the lawyer previously, ask about repeat client discounts. If you're part of a mortgage broker's regular client stream, the lawyer might offer preferential rates to maintain that relationship.
For straightforward refinancing, ask if the lawyer offers fixed-fee packages that might be more economical than hourly billing. Some lawyers provide special rates for simple transactions to attract clients who might use them for more complex, higher-value work in the future.
If you're refinancing multiple properties simultaneously or expect to do additional legal work in the near future, mention this as it might justify reduced rates for your immediate refinancing.
Be respectful when negotiating—lawyers are professionals providing valuable services, not commodity providers. Frame negotiations around value rather than just price, and recognize that modest fee differences might not be worth sacrificing quality service.
Valuation Costs: Understanding Property Assessment Fees
Property valuation is essential for refinancing, but the costs and methods vary significantly depending on your circumstances.
Why Valuations Are Required
Your new lender requires current valuation to confirm your property's market value for several important reasons. They need to verify that the amount they're lending you is appropriate relative to the property's value, ensuring their security position is sound.
The valuation determines your loan-to-value ratio, which affects the interest rate you're offered, whether you need lenders mortgage insurance, and your overall borrowing capacity. It protects both you and the lender from overvaluing the property, which could leave the lender undersecured or you overleveraged.
Even if you recently purchased the property or obtained a valuation for another purpose, lenders typically require fresh valuations because property values change, lenders need valuations conducted to their specifications, and they want independent, current assessment of the security they're accepting.
Types of Valuations and Their Costs
Several valuation methods exist, each with different costs and appropriate use cases.
Automated or desktop valuations are the least expensive option, typically costing nothing to two hundred dollars. These use sophisticated algorithms, recent sales data, and property databases to estimate value without physical inspection. They're suitable for standard properties in active markets with good comparable sales data, lower-risk loans with strong borrower profiles, and properties that have been valued recently with no significant changes.
However, automated valuations have limitations. They can't account for property-specific factors like condition, renovations, or location nuances. They're less accurate for unusual properties, properties in thin markets with few sales, or properties with unique features or issues.
Kerbside or drive-by valuations involve a valuer viewing the property exterior without entering, typically costing two hundred to four hundred dollars. The valuer confirms the property exists, matches official records, and notes obvious external condition issues while comparing it to similar properties in the area.
This method provides more confidence than desktop valuations while keeping costs moderate. It's appropriate for moderate-risk loans where visual confirmation is desired but full inspection isn't necessary.
Full registered valuations include comprehensive interior and exterior inspection by a registered valuer, resulting in detailed reports typically costing six hundred to one thousand dollars or more. The valuer inspects all rooms and areas, assesses condition and quality of construction, notes any issues or required repairs, measures and confirms property details, and prepares a comprehensive written report with photographs.
This method is required for high-risk loans or high loan-to-value ratios, unusual or unique properties, properties with known or suspected issues, and high-value or complex properties where accuracy is critical.
Occasionally, specialized valuations cost even more. Properties with complex issues, multiple dwellings, or commercial components might require valuations exceeding fifteen hundred dollars depending on complexity.
Who Pays for Valuations
You pay for the property valuation even though the lender requires it. This might seem unfair, but it's standard practice because you're the one benefiting from the refinancing and seeking the lender's services.
Some lenders include valuation costs in their overall fee structure, while others charge separately. When comparing lenders, consider whether valuation costs are included or additional to understand true total costs.
Occasionally, lenders offer promotions where they cover valuation costs for certain borrowers or during specific periods. These promotions can save you several hundred dollars, making them worth considering if rates and other terms are competitive.
Factors Affecting Valuation Costs
Several factors influence how much your valuation costs. Property location affects valuers' travel time and expenses, with remote or hard-to-access properties costing more. Property type matters, as standard residential properties are simpler and less expensive to value than lifestyle blocks, properties with multiple dwellings, or unusual properties requiring specialist knowledge.
Property size and complexity increase costs for large properties requiring more inspection time or complex properties with multiple buildings or unusual features. The valuation method required by your lender is perhaps the largest factor, with automated valuations costing least and comprehensive registered valuations costing most.
Market conditions can also affect availability and pricing. During busy periods when valuers are in high demand, costs might increase and turnaround times extend.
When Valuations Come in Lower Than Expected
If your property values below your expectations, several outcomes are possible. You might need to accept a lower loan amount if the valuation reduces your available equity. You might need to contribute additional cash to meet your lender's loan-to-value ratio requirements. Or your interest rate might increase if your LVR moves into a higher-risk category.
You can challenge low valuations by providing evidence of comparable sales the valuer might have missed, documenting recent improvements or renovations not reflected in the valuation, or requesting a second valuation if you believe the first was genuinely inaccurate.
However, recognize that valuations reflect professional opinion based on market evidence. If your property genuinely values less than you hoped, accepting this reality is usually more productive than fighting an accurate assessment.
Minimizing Valuation Costs
Several strategies can help reduce valuation expenses. If you have a choice of lenders and all else is equal, choose one likely to accept less expensive valuation methods based on your strong borrower profile and low loan-to-value ratio.
Ensure your property presents well if a physical valuation is required. While you can't change fundamental characteristics, good presentation might prevent the valuer from noting condition concerns that could reduce the valuation. Complete minor repairs before valuation, ensure the property is clean and tidy, and provide information about recent renovations or improvements.
If you've had a recent valuation for another purpose, provide this to your lender. While they'll likely still require their own valuation, having recent information might allow them to accept a less expensive valuation method.
Application Fees: Understanding Lender Charges
Application fees cover your lender's administrative costs for processing your refinancing application, though these fees vary widely between lenders.
What Application Fees Cover
Application fees compensate lenders for processing your application through their systems, conducting credit checks and verifying information, assessing your financial position and serviceability, preparing loan documentation, and providing customer service throughout the application process.
From the lender's perspective, they incur these costs regardless of whether your application is ultimately approved. The fee ensures they're compensated for their work even if your application is declined or you withdraw before settlement.
Typical Application Fee Ranges
Application fees in New Zealand typically range from zero to eight hundred dollars depending on the lender, loan type, and whether any promotions are running. Major banks often charge three hundred to six hundred dollars as standard, while some specialist lenders or mortgage providers charge more.
Low-cost or online lenders sometimes advertise zero application fees to attract customers, though they might compensate through slightly higher interest rates or other charges. Premium or specialist lenders might charge higher application fees, particularly for complex loans or borrowers requiring additional assessment.
When Application Fees Are Waived
Many lenders waive application fees during promotional periods to attract new customers or refinancers. These promotions are common during competitive periods when lenders are fighting for market share.
Some lenders waive fees for high-value borrowers with excellent credit, substantial equity, and large loan amounts. If you're a strong borrower, ask whether the lender will waive application fees to secure your business.
Refinancing with your existing lender sometimes results in waived application fees as a loyalty benefit, though you should still negotiate to ensure you're getting competitive rates and terms overall.
Application Fees Versus Establishment Fees
Some lenders charge both application fees and separate establishment or setup fees. This can seem like double-charging, and in some cases it effectively is. Always ask for a complete breakdown of all fees so you understand total costs rather than being surprised by additional charges.
When comparing lenders, consider total fees rather than individual components. A lender charging a four hundred dollar application fee with no other charges might be more economical than one charging two hundred dollars in application fees plus three hundred dollars in establishment fees.
Non-Refundable Nature of Application Fees
Application fees are typically non-refundable, even if your application is declined or you withdraw. This creates some risk when applying to multiple lenders, as you might pay several application fees before securing approval.
To minimize this risk, seek pre-approval or indicative offers before committing to formal applications with associated fees. Pre-approval usually doesn't involve fees but gives you confidence about likely approval before you invest in formal applications.
If you're declined after paying an application fee, ask the lender for detailed feedback about why. This information helps you address issues before applying elsewhere, potentially avoiding additional declined applications and wasted fees.
Negotiating Application Fees
Application fees are negotiable with many lenders, particularly if you're a strong borrower or bringing substantial business. Point out competitor offers or promotions as leverage, asking your preferred lender to match or beat these terms.
Mortgage brokers often have more success negotiating fee waivers than individual borrowers because they bring regular business to lenders. This is another advantage of using broker services rather than approaching lenders directly.
Even if a lender won't waive application fees entirely, they might reduce them or offer other concessions like paying your legal fees or providing cashback that effectively offsets the application fee.
Comparing Fees Across the Market
Understanding what fees are typical helps you identify when you're being overcharged or when you're getting exceptional value.
Creating a Comparison Matrix
When evaluating multiple lenders, create a spreadsheet comparing all fees including application or establishment fees, valuation costs (if charged separately), indicative legal costs, any other disclosed charges, and total upfront fees before considering interest rates.
This comprehensive view prevents you from being misled by lenders emphasizing low fees in one category while charging more in others.
Considering the Complete Package
Don't evaluate fees in isolation from interest rates and loan features. A lender with zero fees but an interest rate zero point three percent higher than competitors will cost you thousands more in interest over time, far exceeding any fee savings.
Conversely, a lender charging slightly higher fees but offering significantly better rates or valuable features often represents better overall value.
Calculate the total cost of borrowing over various time horizons—one year, five years, and the full loan term—to understand which offer genuinely provides best value when combining fees and interest costs.
Red Flags to Watch For
Be wary of lenders with unusually high fees that seem disproportionate to the services provided. Hidden fees not disclosed upfront until you're committed to the application represent poor practice. Fees that seem designed to lock you into the lender or make it expensive to leave later are also concerning.
Pressure to commit quickly before you have time to fully understand all fees and terms should always raise suspicions. Reputable lenders give you time to review and compare offers without high-pressure tactics.
Getting the Best Value for Your Money
Smart strategies help ensure you're getting fair value for the fees you pay.
Bundling Services Strategically
Sometimes bundling services with one provider reduces overall costs. Using a lawyer who works regularly with your mortgage broker might result in preferential rates. Consolidating your banking relationship with your new lender might generate fee waivers or discounts.
However, only bundle services where it genuinely makes sense. Don't accept inferior service or products just to access fee discounts that might be offset by other disadvantages.
Timing Your Refinancing Thoughtfully
Refinance during promotional periods when lenders offer fee waivers or discounts. Watch for these promotions, particularly in competitive markets where lenders are fighting for customers.
However, don't delay refinancing unnecessarily just to wait for perfect promotional timing. The interest you continue paying at higher rates while waiting for fee waivers might exceed any fee savings.
Leveraging Professional Relationships
Mortgage brokers often negotiate better fee terms than individual borrowers can achieve due to their volume relationships with lenders. This alone can justify using broker services even when they're compensated through lender commissions rather than charging you directly.
Similarly, lawyers who work regularly with specific lenders or mortgage brokers might offer preferential rates to maintain those relationships, with savings passed along to you.
Understanding When Fees Reflect Value
Sometimes higher fees reflect genuinely superior service or specialized expertise worth paying for. A more expensive lawyer who prevents costly mistakes or provides clearer guidance adds value beyond their fee. A lender charging slightly higher fees but offering exceptional service, better technology, or more suitable loan features might be worth the extra cost.
Evaluate fees in context rather than simply choosing the cheapest option in every category. Value, not just cost, should drive your decisions.
The Bottom Line on Refinancing Fees
Legal fees, valuation costs, and application charges are unavoidable aspects of refinancing, but understanding what you're paying for helps you ensure you're getting fair value. By knowing typical fee ranges, what services these fees cover, and how to negotiate or minimize costs, you can manage your refinancing expenses effectively while still receiving quality service.
At Luminate Financial Group, we help our clients understand and minimize refinancing fees by obtaining quotes from multiple lenders and comparing total costs, negotiating fee waivers and discounts on your behalf, recommending efficient, cost-effective lawyers from our network, explaining exactly what each fee covers and whether it's reasonable, and identifying promotions or opportunities to reduce overall expenses.
Our goal is ensuring you understand all costs upfront with no surprises and securing the best possible value for your refinancing investment. We succeed when you achieve your refinancing goals at fair prices with excellent service.
Want help understanding and minimizing your refinancing fees? Contact Luminate Financial Group today. We'll break down all costs, negotiate on your behalf, and ensure you're getting the best value for your refinancing investment.
